ROAD TO GLORY RTG-01 · Underdog Run · Week 0

Who Knows What

RTG-01 · Who-knows-what tracker · Preseason, Week 0

No two people in this universe are operating off the same set of facts. Any line of dialogue is generated from this table, never from the canon tracker. A teacher whose only source is the school paper cannot cite anything buried in the HUDL analytics.

The five facts

The five columns are the only facts that currently matter. A — how good he really is. B — that not a single college program has reached out to him. C — that he is emailing schools himself. D — the state of his kidney. E — the Perkins conflict.

Sixth fact, added Wednesday, August 26. A pair of FBS position coaches, Ball State's Craig Harmon and Wyoming's Christian Taylor, wrote back, sat down with the film, and requested additional tape. Nobody offered him anything.

Who knows: Nick. Ari, who keeps the spreadsheet and has been given the number of replies and no other detail.
Who does not know: everyone else. Shaffer and Setzke, his mother and father, Karenna, Tommy, Hudson, Ben, the roster, the student body, and the Tri-County Times. For a month Shaffer has been working his personal contacts and gotten nowhere, which is the precise reason Nick is keeping quiet about his own replies.
PersonA · TalentB · No contactC · Self-outreach D · HealthE · Music
Nick Is confident he can play college football somewhere, has no idea at what tier, and knows nobody qualified to tell him Knows exactly It's his Medically cleared, ten months without contact, and dwelling on it far more than he lets on Committed to Sundays. Has not picked his three pieces.
Paul Shaffer Convinced. Cannot get anyone to look. Knows, and deliberately put it on the student broadcast Knows Knows he's cleared. Worries about the first hit. Knows — Perkins phoned him regarding Thursdays and he handled it graciously
Jeff Setzke Knows he wins games. Has never considered the kid's ceiling and does not regard that as his responsibility. Knows and considers it a distraction Is unaware, and would not take it well Knows he's cleared; that closes the subject Unaware
Furhut (Mom) Knows he's good at it. Has no framework for how good. Has not really processed it as a problem Does not know Knows more than anyone. It is why he missed the playoff run. Received a copy of the Perkins email and has yet to answer it
Jerry (Dad) Proud, no calibration, learning off the internet Knows. Asks about it roughly every 48 hours. Knows Knows he's cleared Unaware
Ari Holds no opinion on the sport; approaches it purely as scheduling Tracks it in a spreadsheet column Built the system Knows Unaware
Karenna Doesn't think about it Doesn't know Doesn't know Knows about the hospital stay and how badly it frightened the household Unaware
Tommy Quinn Believes it without understanding it Knows Knows Knows Knows — he's in the room
Hudson Believes it, and must be cautious about committing that belief to print Reported it. Printed it. Knows the number: nine. Knows Knows part of it. Has not printed any of it.
Ben Haijcar Understands it more clearly than nearly anyone, having lived through the same thing Knows Doesn't know Knows he's cleared Unaware
Kevin Lack Rates him as accurate and credits him with delivering the football. Refuses to weigh in on anyone else's ceiling while his own is unresolved. Vaguely aware, hasn't thought about it Doesn't know Assumes fine Unaware
Troy Holds that his cousin is the greatest player breathing; should not be trusted on this Learned it watching Tiger Television and did not take it well Knows, and volunteered to make it worse Knows Unaware
Mr. Perkins Watched the Linden game. Understood what he saw. Says so. Suspects. Has not asked. Doesn't know Aware there was an injury; has none of the specifics It's his whole file
Mrs. Grady Knows the writer, not the quarterback Doesn't know Doesn't know Doesn't know Doesn't know
Mr. Gilbert Actively hostile to the idea. "Against who? I played in this league." Ran a freshman team back in the nineties and considers that credential sufficient. Doesn't know Doesn't know Doesn't know Doesn't know
Principal Bakker Did not know Nick existed before football. Asked "is he the tall one?" Currently very excited about someone he could not pick out of a lineup. Doesn't know Doesn't know Doesn't know Doesn't know
Hannah Believes the school version Doesn't know Doesn't know Doesn't know Doesn't know
Sylvia Does not frame any of it through football Doesn't know Doesn't know Doesn't know Knows about the piano, and knew before anybody else did
The student body Takes for granted that big programs are already after him Wrong. Partly walked back by Shaffer on air, and that correction is now circulating. Unaware Assumes fine A single Yik Yak thread landed on the truth
Wes Trombley (media) Has read the production but not watched the tape, and admitted as much Assumes it, correctly Unaware Knows there's no postseason film and why Unaware he plays anything
Craig Harmon
Ball State, QBs
Has watched twelve minutes of it, including one throw he says is unteachable. Will not commit further without a complete game. Assumes it Knows, which is how the email reached him in the first place Doesn't know about the injury Unaware
Christian Taylor
Wyoming, OC/QBs
Tested him on five concepts and got five correct responses. Considers the processing genuine and says the only gap is documentation. Assumes it Knows Doesn't know Unaware
Everyone else in college football Have no knowledge of him whatsoever, apart from one unnamed party in Allendale — Of the first nine, four clicked a link; the Michigan State message went unopened — —
Seventh fact, added Wednesday night. The anonymous Yik Yak account that spent seven days going after its own quarterback belongs to Brendan Matthews.

Knows: Kevin Lack, who clocked a phrase Brendan had said to his face in the lot on Tuesday. Nick, who was told at 11:41 p.m. and had already read every post. Brendan himself.
Does not know: Brendan has no idea anyone has connected the account to him. No coach knows. Ben doesn't know. Troy especially has no idea, a fact Nick has noticed and which is the real reason he has kept quiet.
Suspects: the herd — a handful of replies pegged it as an offensive player broadcasting from 0.1 mi away, and one user wrongly fingered Troy.
Eighth fact, added Thursday, August 27, 11:41 p.m. Nick's parents now know he has been emailing college programs himself. Furhut gave him edit access to her shared document on Sunday, on purpose. On Thursday night he left a two-character comment — 12 — under her line reading "schools we have contacted: 0," and sent her the spreadsheet at 12:09 a.m.

Now knows: Furhut; Jerry, told at 11:58 p.m. in a thread Nick is not in.
Still does not know: Karenna, Ben, the team, the school, the Tri-County Times. Setzke found out separately on August 26, when Shaffer mentioned it in passing, which is not how Nick intended anybody to find out.
What happens next: the parents have agreed between themselves to sit him down on Saturday and ask what he needs. Neither mentioned any of it before Friday's kickoff. He does not know they talked.
Ninth fact — a correction, and who is still wrong about it. Jeff Setzke has never read Nick's 2024 column. The story that the column got him into the program is false, and this universe has repeated it for two years because The Fentonian printed it first.

Knows the truth: Setzke, who always did. Hudson, Pearce and the paper, as of August 21. Renata Kilbourne at the Tri-County Times. Ryan Zuke. The student body, unevenly and at volume.
Told this month and took it quietly: Nick — "Okay… that actually makes more sense than the other version."
Still believes the old version: most adults in Fenton, Principal Bakker, Mr. Gilbert, the Linden booster group, and everybody who has not read page 4.
Does not care either way: Marty Sitko, who volunteered that he has not read the column and is not going to start now.
The push, and why it failed. Four people independently told Nick to stop waiting and go get seen — Shaffer (since April), Kobe Lookebill (nine times in the weight room), Chase Lynch (who understands precisely why the emails land in his inbox and not Nick's), and Hudson (a June conversation in a driveway, later made public in print). Nick agreed with all four and did nothing, and every one of them read that as unwillingness.

It was not unwillingness, and this is the most important entry on this page. He knew camps existed and did not know they were the gate; he believed good film gets watched. "Go to a camp" was said to him four times by four people and unpacked by none of them. By the time he understood the instruction it was July and the calendar was gone. On the record: "It's not that I didn't want to go. Nobody told us, and then I was slow, and then it was over. And I'm a senior, so there isn't another June."

Shaffer has publicly taken the blame for assuming the phrase meant something to a seventeen-year-old. Hudson spent two months believing he was being ignored and printed that he was wrong. Kobe and Chase still do not know. None of the four knows the other three had the same conversation — each believes he was the only one.

Active misconceptions

"He was on visits all summer"

Held by: most of the school

His summer was shifts at Culver's, six o'clock lifts, and Sunday throwing sessions with two receivers. The Fentonian ran a correction on Friday. A correction never moves as quickly as the error it chases.

"My cousin knows a guy"

Held by: a sophomore, and now others

An unsourced rumor that a Power Four school is a done deal, and it is beating the truth around the building by a wide margin.

"Ben got moved off safety"

Held by: Yik Yak

False. Tuesday he opened at free safety and logged eight snaps in the change-up package.

"He's 145 pounds"

Believed by: one Goodrich student, and the printed roster

He weighed in at 155 on Monday. That roster lists 149 for the simple reason that it went to the printer in June. Twice in seven days he has volunteered a correction in the group chat, unasked, at measurable expense to his pride.

"He was a band kid"

Believed by: Gilbert, Kevin Lack, and most of the building, as shorthand for "not a real athlete"

Technically true and completely misleading. First chair trombone since ninth grade and the finest pianist in the school — Perkins, twenty-six years on the job, calls him the best musician he has ever taught. This building has never drawn a line between "was in band" and "was the best musician in the band," and the latter earned him precisely nothing until a football left his hand. Perkins put that on the record in Friday's paper. At press time there has been no response from anyone.

"Football and music are in conflict"

Held by: Nick, about Perkins

Perkins stated plainly that this is not his position. Nick assumed it anyway and admitted it. The conflict is real; the antagonism isn't.

"Nobody has watched the film"

Held by: Nick

Somebody inside Grand Valley State ran the full highlight reel twice and then sat through forty-one minutes of raw game footage. He has no idea. HUDL does not tell you who.

"Nobody called"

Believed by: the whole school, accurately, right up until Tuesday

It was accurate as of Friday's press run. It stopped being true at 9:48 p.m. on Tuesday. No one beyond the Mansour family is aware of it, and that headline is still in a pile by the front door.

← Previous
HUDL outreach log
Next →
Relationship ledger
THE SHELF · 26 of 28  ·  Week 0 index
RTG-01 — Underdog Run
Knowledge-state tracker · Week 0 / Preseason